Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting vs Umbrel

Two self-hosted Self-hosting Solutions apps, compared on the facts we track: GitHub popularity and activity, license, language, Docker images and a rough hosting estimate.

Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting and Umbrel are open-source Self-hosting Solutions apps you can run on your own server. On GitHub, Umbrel leads with 12.5k stars against 1.2k for Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting (about 11× as many). Both are actively developed, with commits in the past 90 days.

Side by side

Mother-of-All-Self-HostingUmbrel
DescriptionAnsible playbook which helps you host services as Docker containers on your own server.Beautiful personal server OS for self-hosting. Install on a Raspberry Pi 4 or Ubuntu/Debian.
GitHub stars1,17412,546
Forks––
Open issues––
Commits (12 months)1.8k651
Last activity2026-11-102026-11-03
Latest release–2.1.0-beta.1 (2026-11-03)
Score (0–100)8092
Maintenance healthActiveActive
LicenseAGPL-3.0⊘ Proprietary
Language / platformAnsible, DockerNodejs, Docker
Docker Hub image––
Docker pulls––
Est. server size~1 GB, 1 vCPU~1 GB, 1 vCPU
Est. hosting from$5/mo$5/mo
CategoriesSelf-hosting SolutionsSelf-hosting Solutions
LinksWebsite · SourceWebsite · Source

What the numbers say

Summary: Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting leads on commit activity; Umbrel leads on GitHub popularity. The right choice depends on the features you need — read both project descriptions and docs.

This summary is generated from GitHub, Docker Hub and awesome-selfhosted data as of 2026-11-16. It does not rate features or quality.

How the score works

Each app gets a score out of 100, computed only from public data we refresh daily:

The score measures community size, upkeep and ease of deployment, not features or quality. Hover a score to see its parts.

Host Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting or Umbrel

Either app fits on a ~1 GB VPS by our rough estimate. Cheapest matching plans:

ProviderPlan size~ USD / month
Vultr
Low-cost cloud compute in 30+ regions.
1 GB$5Deploy →
Akamai (Linode)
Long-running VPS provider with predictable pricing.
1 GB$5Deploy →
DigitalOcean
Simple droplets, great docs, 1-click Docker image.
1 GB$6Deploy →

Prefer managed hosting? Check PikaPods or Elestio.

Estimate from each app's stack and category, not a benchmark. Some hosting links may be affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you; it never affects which apps we list.

Frequently asked questions

Is Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting or Umbrel more popular?

Umbrel has more GitHub stars (12,546 vs 1,174 for Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting, as of 2026-11-16). Stars measure interest, not quality.

Which is more actively maintained, Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting or Umbrel?

Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting had more commits over the last 12 months (1,843 vs 651). The last recorded activity was 2026-11-10 for Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting and 2026-11-03 for Umbrel. Releases in the past year: Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting 0, Umbrel 10+. Our health labels: Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting is “Active”, Umbrel is “Active”.

What licenses do Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting and Umbrel use?

Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting: AGPL-3.0. Umbrel: ⊘ Proprietary. Note: Umbrel includes a non-free license component.

Can I run Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting and Umbrel with Docker?

We did not detect a Docker Hub image for either app. The upstream listing mentions Docker as a deployment option for Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting and Umbrel. Check each project's documentation for install options.

Read more

Mother-of-All-Self-Hosting

Ansible playbook which helps you host services as Docker containers on your own server.

Active ★ 1.2k AGPL-3.0 🐳 Docker~$5/mo

Umbrel

Beautiful personal server OS for self-hosting. Install on a Raspberry Pi 4 or Ubuntu/Debian.

Active ★ 12.5k ⊘ Proprietary 🐳 Docker~$5/mo

Browse all self-hosted Self-hosting Solutions apps, or see every cPanel alternative.

Related comparisons

DietPi vs Mother-of-All-Self-HostingMother-of-All-Self-Hosting vs Websoft9Tipi vs UmbrelSandstorm vs UmbrelOpenMediaVault vs UmbrelDietPi vs UmbrelCosmos vs UmbrelUmbrel vs Websoft9HomelabOS vs Umbrel